Your feelings are data, not verdicts.

Feelings push choices in particular directions, often without your noticing. That doesn’t make them wrong. What matters is telling a feeling about the decision, which is often useful, from one carried in from the rest of your day, which is the real bias, and naming it in one precise word before you choose.
Specific feelings, specific pushes
That emotions shape decisions is mainstream science (Lerner et al., 2015, a review). The useful part is that specific feelings push in specific ways, and “good mood or bad mood” misses it.
Fear and anger are both unpleasant, yet in one lab’s studies fear pushed people toward caution and anger toward optimism and risk (Lerner & Keltner, 2000, 2001). Later tests have been mixed, so treat it as a tendency to check, not a law. Sadness has its own pull: with real money at stake, sad people were more impatient, taking less now over more later (Lerner, Li & Weber, 2013).
About the decision, or about your day?
A feeling about the choice itself is often information. Unease about a job offer may be telling you something about the job. A feeling carried in from something unrelated, an argument this morning or a bad night, is the clear bias (Han, Lerner & Keltner, 2007, a review). One question sorts most of them: is this about the decision, or about my day?
Name it, in one word
Putting a feeling into words takes some of the heat out of it, at least in the lab (Torre & Lieberman, 2018, a review). Whether that makes the decision better is inferred, not shown. Precision seems to matter more than effort: investors who named their feelings precisely made better trading decisions (Seo & Barrett, 2007, one study).
Keep it short. One word is enough. Long analyses of how you feel can make it harder to see the situation differently afterwards.
One question for each feeling
Afraid: is the safe choice here just the afraid one? Anxious: are you past your first answer, or just ready for this to stop? Angry: are you choosing the result, or the release?
Excited: would you still want this through the boring parts? Excitement isn’t a warning sign; it is what gets most things started. Hopeful: is it likely, or what you’d like to be true? Impatient: would this still be your choice with another week?
Envious: would you want it if no one else had it? Guilty: is this what you want, or what you feel you owe? Bored: is it the right change, or just a change? Tired: would this look the same after a good night’s sleep? Short sleep makes feelings louder. Sad: are you reaching for the quick fix because you feel low? Calm: what happens next, and after that? Calm isn’t automatically right.
And the gut?
A gut feeling is trustworthy under narrow conditions: a predictable situation, and plenty of practice with quick, clear feedback (Kahneman & Klein, 2009). Most life decisions, like a move, a job or a relationship, don’t meet them. Feeling sure is not evidence of being right. Your gut is still worth writing down, because it is one more piece of data.
More questions
Should I wait until I feel calm to decide?
Waiting for a strong feeling to fade helps, but calm isn’t automatically right. Ask what happens next, and after that, whatever you feel.
Is it bad to decide while excited?
No. Excitement is what starts most good things. The risk is the rosy forecast, so ask whether you would still want it through the boring parts.
Sources
- Lerner JS, Li Y, Valdesolo P, Kassam KS (2015). Emotion and decision making. Annual Review of Psychology 66.
- Lerner JS, Keltner D (2001). Fear, anger, and risk. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 81(1).
- Lerner JS, Li Y, Weber EU (2013). The financial costs of sadness. Psychological Science 24(1).
- Han S, Lerner JS, Keltner D (2007). Feelings and consumer decision making. Journal of Consumer Psychology 17(3).
- Torre JB, Lieberman MD (2018). Putting feelings into words. Emotion Review 10(2).
- Seo M-G, Barrett LF (2007). Being emotional during decision making. Academy of Management Journal 50(4).
- Kahneman D, Klein G (2009). Conditions for intuitive expertise. American Psychologist 64(6).