One counterpoint helps. A long list backfires.
Replicated. Considering the opposite is well repeated; the backfire is one study.
Considering the opposite of your view reduces bias, and that has been repeated many times. But when people were asked for a long list of counterarguments, their bias got worse, because coming up with so many felt hard, and the difficulty itself seemed like evidence.
What it shows
Asking people to consider why the opposite might be true reduced biased reading of evidence and anchoring (Lord, Lepper & Preston, 1984; Hirt & Markman, 1995). Asking for many reasons the other way had the reverse effect (Sanna, Schwarz & Stocker, 2002).
How to use it
Write the single best case against what you’re leaning toward. One, not a count. If another occurs to you later, add it. Don’t go looking for a quota.