Ask yourself twice.
Replicated. Repeated by independent groups, including in very large samples.
When people answer the same question twice and average their answers, the average tends to beat both. The second answer helps more when it comes later. It helps even more when it comes from someone else.
What it shows
Your second guess carries some information your first one missed, because it was made in a slightly different state of mind (Vul & Pashler, 2008). The effect held in three large natural experiments (van Dolder & van den Assem, 2018). The extra gain from a longer gap is only partly repeated (Steegen et al., 2014).
Making the second look count
A second judgment adds most when it is independent of the first. Assuming your first answer was wrong before making the second one adds more still (Herzog & Hertwig, 2009). For a decision, that means choosing again at decision time before looking back at what you leaned toward when you started.
Sources
- Vul E, Pashler H (2008). Measuring the crowd within. Psychological Science 19(7).
- van Dolder D, van den Assem MJ (2018). The wisdom of the inner crowd in three large natural experiments. Nature Human Behaviour 2.
- Steegen S et al. (2014). Measuring the crowd within again. Frontiers in Psychology.
- Herzog SM, Hertwig R (2009). The wisdom of many in one mind. Psychological Science 20(2).