← Questions

Do pros and cons lists actually work?

16 November 2026

Not as well as their reputation. Writing out reasons can pull a choice away from what you actually like, and people who struggle to decide already tend to over-gather. What works better: ask what you want out of the decision, list your options, write one case against your lean, and set a time.

The problem with reasons

In one lab’s studies, analysing reasons for a choice of taste, like a poster or a jam, pulled people’s choices away from what they liked and lowered how satisfied they were later (Wilson & Schooler, 1991). The reasons that are easy to put into words are not always the ones that matter.

What to do instead

Start with what you want out of the decision. People asked about their objectives first came up with more, and better, options (Siebert & Keeney, 2015). Then write your options, one best case against your lean, and a time to decide.

Sources