Should you trust your gut on a big decision?
Record it, but don’t let it decide on its own. A gut feeling is reliable in predictable situations where you have had lots of practice and quick, clear feedback. Most big life decisions, like a move, a job or a relationship, don’t meet those conditions, and feeling sure is not evidence of being right.
When the gut has earned it
Expert intuition is real, in the right conditions: a firefighter reading a building, a nurse noticing a patient is off. It works when the environment is regular enough to learn and the expert has had years of feedback (Kahneman & Klein, 2009, a review). Without those, intuition and confidence come apart.
What to do with it
Write your gut reaction down when the decision first comes up, and again at decision time. If it has held through the wait, that is worth something. If it faded with the mood, that tells you something too. A coin flip can help you see what your gut wants without letting it decide (Jaffé, Reutner & Greifeneder, 2019).