Sleeping on it doesn’t make you surer.
Contested. Studies point in different directions; the best summaries find no effect.
The one direct test of sleeping on a decision found no gain in confidence, and a meta-analysis found no effect of sleep on how strongly people react to emotional material. A night still helps, by putting time between the feeling and the choice. The sleep is not the active part.
What it shows
A well-known study suggested that sleep takes the sting out of emotional memories (van der Helm et al., 2011). Later work did not bear that out, and a meta-analysis found no effect on emotional reactivity (Lipinska et al., 2022). When researchers tested sleeping on a choice directly, confidence did not rise (Karmarkar, Shiv & Spencer, 2017).
The other side of it
Losing sleep is a different matter. Short sleep makes feelings louder (Yoo et al., 2007). So if you are exhausted, a good night before deciding is worth it, not because sleep decides, but because tiredness skews.
Sources
- Lipinska G et al. (2022). Sleep and emotional reactivity, a meta-analysis. Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience.
- Karmarkar UR, Shiv B, Spencer RMC (2017). Should you sleep on it? JBDM 30.
- van der Helm E et al. (2011). REM sleep depotentiates amygdala activity. Current Biology 21.
- Yoo S-S et al. (2007). The human emotional brain without sleep. Current Biology 17(20).